BSI PD IEC TR 63192:2019
$198.66
Nuclear power plants. Instrumentation and control systems important to safety. Hazard analysis: a review of current approaches
Published By | Publication Date | Number of Pages |
BSI | 2019 | 56 |
This document provides the comparison of the hazard analysis requirements between IAEA framework and NRC-IEEE framework of standards and guidance. The hazard analysis requirements in the different standards were compared with a set of comparison criteria, including the safety principle, the safety process, the definitions, the hazard analysis process, etc. This document includes the comparison results of the HA requirements of the safety control systems of other safety industries in Annex C.
For a nuclear power plant, the design safety and operation safety shall be analyzed, for example, to meet the IAEA Safety Requirements for Design (SSR-2/1) and Operation (SSR-2/2). The scope of this document is to survey the state of the art in the hazard analysis for the design of I&C system of NPPs.
Figure 1 illustrates the scope of I&C systems important to safety which have hazard analysis requirements, in the form of a three by three matrix which is in IEEE 603-2009. This document covers the hazard analysis for the sense and command features of digital systems. This document also considers the requirements for hazard analysis of the system of systems(SoS), including the software, hardware and human for the digital systems.
PDF Catalog
PDF Pages | PDF Title |
---|---|
2 | undefined |
4 | CONTENTS |
6 | FOREWORD |
8 | INTRODUCTION |
10 | 1 Scope |
11 | 2 Normative references Figures Figure 1 – I&C Layer and Defence-in-Depth Level |
12 | 3 Terms and definitions |
14 | 4 Terminologies in IAEA-IEC and NRC-IEEE |
15 | Tables Table 1 – Definitions of IAEA and IEEE nuclear standards |
16 | 5 Abbreviated terms and acronyms 6 General 6.1 Hazard analysis of digital instrumentation and control systems |
17 | 6.2 Purpose of hazard analysis Figure 2 – Internal or external hazards |
18 | 7 Comparison of hazard analysis requirements and guidance for nuclear industry 7.1 General Figure 3 – IAEA-IEC framework of I&C standards |
19 | 7.2 IAEA Safety Requirements SSR-2/1: Design Safety of NPP:2012 Figure 4 – NRC-IEEE framework of I&C standards |
20 | 7.3 IAEA Safety Requirements SSR-2/2: Operation Safety of NPP:2012 Table 2 – Hazard Analysis in IAEA Safety Requirements SSR-2/1:2012 |
21 | 7.4 IAEA SSG-39 recommendations for I&C system Hazard Analysis Table 3 – HA requirements in IAEA SSG-39:2016 |
22 | 7.5 IEEE 603 requirements for I&C system Hazard Analysis Table 4 – HA requirements in IEEE Standard 603-2009 |
23 | 7.6 IEEE7-4.3.2-2010 requirements for computer based I&C system Hazard Analysis Table 5 – HA requirements in IEEE7-4.3.2-2010 |
24 | 7.7 IEEE 1228-1994 requirements for I&C software Hazard Analysis |
25 | 7.8 IEEE 1012-2012 requirements for system Hazard Analysis Table 6 – HA requirements in IEEE 1228-1994 |
26 | 7.9 HA Guidance of US NRC Table 7 – HA requirements in IEEE 1012-2012 |
27 | Table 8 – DSRS APPENDIX A. Hazard Analysis |
28 | Table 9 – Research Information Letter of HA review (US NRC RIL 1101:2013) |
29 | 8 MDEP common position on hazard identification and controls for digital I&C systems 8.1 General 8.2 Hazard identification [59] |
30 | 8.3 Hazard control [59] 9 Further works for hazard analysis of I&C for NPPs 9.1 The harmonized HA for I&C system of systems(SoS), software, hardware, and human |
31 | 9.2 The harmonized HA with the security, and reliability of I&C systems Figure 5 – Harmonization of HA requirements for I&C system of systems |
32 | 10 Conclusion Figure 6 – Overall safety assessment |
33 | Annex A (informative)Survey of practical techniques for Hazard Analysis A.1 General A.2 Practical techniques for Hazard Analysis |
34 | A.3 Use of the techniques for performing the HA for I&C systems |
35 | Annex B (informative)Comparison of Hazard Analysis guidanceand requirements of safety industries B.1 [Safety industry general] IEC 61508 requirements for system hazard analysis Table B.1 – HA requirements in the functional safety standard IEC 61508 |
36 | B.2 [Aerospace industry] DO-178C |
37 | Table B.2 – HA requirements in the aerospace safety standards ARP 4761, DO-178C |
38 | B.3 [Air Force System Safety handbook], 2000[63] Table B.3 – HA requirements in Air Force System Safety handbook |
40 | B.4 [Military Industry] MIL-STD-882E (System Safety)[44] Table B.4 – HA requirements in the military safety standard MIL 882 E |
41 | B.5 [Car Safety] ISO 26262 (Auto)[46],[47],[48],[49] |
42 | Table B.5 – HA requirements in the car safety standard ISO 26262 |
44 | B.6 [Railway Industry] IEC 62278:2002(RAMS)[45] |
45 | Table B.6 – HA requirements in the railway safety standard IEC 62278:2002 |
46 | B.7 [Medical Industry] IEC 60601-1:2005, Medical electrical equipment – Part 1: General requirements for basic safety and essential performance[64] |
47 | Table B.7 – HA requirements in the medical safety standard IEC 60601-1:2005 |
49 | Annex C (informative)Comparison criteria of Hazard Analysis requirements C.1 Safety principles (safety model, safety culture) C.2 Safety processes C.3 Definition of HA C.4 Purpose of HA C.5 Method of HA C.6 HA process C.7 Independence of HA (HA organization) |
50 | C.8 Harmonized HA of SoS C.9 Relationship with other requirements (security, reliability) Table C.1 – Comparison criteria |
52 | Bibliography |